13 November 2025
Headlines

IPO Pine Labs & PhysicsWallah

khabrain24011 mins
Khabrain24 Khabrain24
Pine Labs & PhysicsWallah IPO Investment Analysis

Table of Contents

🎯 Comprehensive IPO Analysis: Pine Labs & PhysicsWallah

Expert Investment Perspective for Growth-Oriented Investors

Analysis Date: November 11, 2025 | Delhi NCR Perspective

📊 Executive Summary

Both Pine Labs and PhysicsWallah represent significant opportunities in India’s high-growth fintech and edtech sectors respectively. However, they present distinctly different risk-reward profiles. This analysis examines their business fundamentals, financial performance, growth trajectory, and investment viability.

Pine Labs: ⚠️ CAUTIOUS APPROACH
Wait for listing, monitor 2-3 quarters
PhysicsWallah: ✅ MODERATE BUY
Better fundamentals, manageable risks

🏦 1. PINE LABS IPO – DETAILED ANALYSIS

📊 IPO Structure & Basics

Parameter Details
IPO Dates November 7-11, 2025
Price Band ₹210 – ₹221 per share
Issue Size ₹3,899.91 crore
Fresh Issue ₹2,080 crore
OFS Component ₹1,819.91 crore (47%)
Lot Size 67 shares
Min Investment ₹14,807 (at upper band)
Listing Date November 14, 2025 (Expected)
Post-IPO Valuation ~₹25,654 crore

🏢 Business Model & Operations

Core Business Segments:

Digital Infrastructure (71%)

  • PoS terminals & UPI soundbox
  • Online payment gateway
  • Business analytics

Issuing Platform (29%)

  • Prepaid gift cards (Market leader)
  • BNPL solutions
  • Merchant financing

Geographic Presence: India (primary), Malaysia, UAE, Singapore, Australia, US, Africa

💰 Financial Performance Analysis

Revenue Trajectory

Period Revenue YoY Growth
FY23 ₹1,690 crore –
FY24 ₹1,824 crore 8%
FY25 ₹2,327 crore 27.5% ✅
Q1 FY26 ₹653 crore 22% YoY

Profitability Journey

Period Net Profit/Loss EBITDA Margin PAT Margin
FY23 Loss: ₹265 crore – -15.7%
FY24 Loss: ₹342 crore 8.9% -18.7%
FY25 Loss: ₹145 crore 15.7% ✅ -6.2%
Q1 FY26 Profit: ₹4.8 crore ✅ 19.6% 0.8%
Key Insight: Company turned profitable in Q1 FY26 – a critical inflection point, though aided by ₹14 crore deferred tax credit.

Operational Metrics (FY25)

Gross Transaction Value

₹11.42T
118% YoY growth in Q1 FY26 🚀

Total Transactions

5.68B
Across all platforms

Merchants Served

988,304
As of June 2025

Financial Institutions

177
Partnership network

⚡ Strengths (Why Consider)

  1. Market Leadership Position – Largest player in closed/semi-closed loop gift cards in India
  2. Impressive Operating Leverage – Contribution margin of 76%, EBITDA improved from 8.9% to 19.6%
  3. Robust Transaction Growth – 118% YoY transaction volume growth in Q1 FY26
  4. Blue-Chip Investor Backing – Mastercard, PayPal, Peak XV, Temasek
  5. Growing Market Opportunity – India’s digital payment market: ₹116T (FY25) → ₹256-276T (FY29)

⚠️ Red Flags & Concerns

🚨 1. VALUATION CONCERNS – MAJOR RED FLAG

  • P/E Ratio: 1,340x (based on annualized Q1 FY26 profit)
  • Peer Comparison: Zaggle trades at 48x P/E
  • Verdict: Extremely expensive, pricing in 5-10 years of future growth

2. Rising Debt Levels

  • Debt-to-Equity ratio: 9% (FY23) → 25% (FY25)
  • Total borrowings: ₹888 crore (Q1 FY26)

3. Negative Cash Flows

  • Q1 FY26: Negative ₹281 crore from operations
  • FY24: Negative ₹229 crore
  • FY23: Negative ₹152 crore
  • Concern: Company burning cash despite revenue growth

4. Customer Concentration Risk

  • Top 10 customers: 31% of revenue (Q1 FY26)
  • Loss of major client could significantly impact revenue

5. Profitability Sustainability Concerns

  • Only 1 quarter of profit (Q1 FY26)
  • Helped by ₹14 crore tax credit (one-time benefit)
  • Not yet proven as consistently profitable

6. Weak Grey Market Premium (GMP)

  • GMP dropped from ₹35 (Nov 3) to ₹4 (Nov 10) – 88% decline! 🔴
  • Current GMP: ₹12 (only 5.4% listing gain expected)
  • Signal: Weak investor enthusiasm

7. Large OFS Component

  • ₹1,820 crore being sold by existing investors (47% of issue)
  • Peak XV Partners selling ₹508 crore (39x return)
  • Mastercard, PayPal, and 30+ investors exiting
  • Concern: Smart money is taking profits

💡 Use of IPO Proceeds

  1. Debt Repayment: ₹532 crore (reducing interest burden) ✅
  2. Technology & Devices: ₹760 crore
    • ₹430 crore for DCP terminals and soundboxes
    • ₹230 crore for cloud infrastructure
    • ₹100 crore for AI and data analytics
  3. International Expansion
  4. General Corporate Purposes

🎯 Investment Recommendation: PINE LABS

Rating: ⚠️ AVOID/WAIT (For IPO Subscription)

Reasoning:

NEGATIVES OUTWEIGH POSITIVES:

  1. Absurd Valuation: P/E of 1,340x is unjustifiable even for high-growth fintech
  2. Unproven Profitability: Only 1 quarter of profit (tax-credit aided)
  3. Cash Flow Concerns: Negative operating cash flow is worrying
  4. Weak Market Sentiment: GMP crashed 88% – clear red flag
  5. Smart Money Exiting: Large OFS with investors booking 39x returns

POSITIVES ARE REAL BUT INSUFFICIENT:

  1. Strong business model and market position
  2. Improving margins and operational efficiency
  3. Good growth trajectory

Read More on

📋 STRATEGY FOR INVESTORS

For Short-Term Traders:

  • ❌ AVOID: GMP suggests minimal listing gains (5-6% max)
  • High risk of listing at discount given weak subscription

For Long-Term Growth Investors:

  • ⏰ WAIT FOR LISTING: Let price discover true value
  • 📊 MONITOR 2-3 QUARTERS: Validate sustained profitability
  • 💰 BUY ON DIPS: If stock corrects 20-30% post-listing with intact fundamentals
  • 🎯 TARGET ENTRY: Around ₹150-170 range (30-40% below issue price)

Risk Level

🔴 HIGH

Expected Listing Gain

0-5%
(possibly negative)

Long-Term Potential

Good*
*only at right valuation

🎓 2. PHYSICSWALLAH IPO – DETAILED ANALYSIS

📊 IPO Structure & Basics

Parameter Details
IPO Dates November 11-13, 2025
Price Band ₹103 – ₹109 per share
Issue Size ₹3,480 crore
Fresh Issue ₹3,100 crore (89%)
OFS Component ₹380 crore (11%)
Lot Size 137 shares
Min Investment ₹14,933 (at upper band)
Listing Date November 18, 2025 (Expected)
Post-IPO Valuation ~₹31,000 crore
Anchor Investment ₹1,563 crore (secured) ✅

🏢 Business Model & Operations

Founded: 2014 (YouTube channel) → 2020 (Company incorporation)
Founders: Alakh Pandey (CEO) & Prateek Maheshwari (Co-founder)

Core Business Segments:

Online Courses (86%)

  • JEE/NEET prep (42% users)
  • Government exam prep
  • Foundation courses
  • Skill development

Offline/Hybrid Centers

  • Physical centers in 200+ cities
  • Hybrid learning model

Ancillary Revenue

  • Student accommodations: ₹87.7 cr
  • Merchandise: ₹259.3 cr
  • YouTube ads: ₹7.9 cr
Market Position:
  • Top 5 education companies by revenue
  • Largest online student community in India
  • 13.7 million YouTube subscribers (main channel)
  • 98.8 million total subscribers across 207 channels

💰 Financial Performance Analysis

Revenue Growth Story

Period Revenue YoY Growth
FY23 ₹744 crore –
FY24 ₹1,940 crore 160% 🚀
FY25 ₹2,887 crore 49% 🚀
CAGR (FY23-25) 97% – Exceptional!

Profitability Trajectory

Period Net Profit/Loss EBITDA EBITDA Margin
FY23 Loss: ₹84 crore – –
FY24 Loss: ₹1,131 crore* Loss: ₹829 crore -42.7%
FY25 Loss: ₹243 crore Profit: ₹193 crore ✅ 6.7% ✅
Important Note on FY24 Loss:
  • Reported loss: ₹1,131 crore
  • Non-cash expenses: ₹756 crore (CCPS fair value adjustment)
  • Actual cash loss: ₹375 crore
  • ESOP expenses: ₹151 crore (non-cash)

Key Achievement: Company turned EBITDA profitable in FY25 – first time since inception!

Cost Structure Improvement

Operating Leverage Working:

  • Total expenses: ₹3,279 crore (FY24) → ₹3,265 crore (FY25)
  • Revenue up 49%, expenses down 0.4%
  • Result: Margins expanding rapidly ✅

⚡ Strengths (Why Consider)

1. 🌟 Exceptional Brand & Market Position

  • Most searched and recognized edtech brand in India (FY25)
  • 98.8 million YouTube subscribers
  • Strong word-of-mouth and organic growth
  • Brand trust among students and parents

2. 💰 Affordable Pricing = Massive TAM

Course PhysicsWallah Price Competitor Price
JEE Course ₹4,500/year ₹63,000-110,000
NEET Course ₹4,800/year ₹60,000-100,000
UPSC Course ₹18,000/year ₹80,000-150,000

Impact: Accessible to middle-class India (massive market)

3. 📈 Strong Financial Turnaround

  • EBITDA profitable in FY25 (first time ever)
  • Revenue CAGR of 97% (FY23-25)
  • Reduced marketing spend (organic growth)
  • Improving unit economics

4. 🤖 Technology & AI Integration

  • 548-member technology team
  • AI Guru: 2.82 million student queries/month
  • Smart Doubt Engine: Instant resolution
  • AI Grader: 304,202 responses evaluated (Aug 2024-June 2025)

5. Diversified Revenue Streams

  • 13 education categories (vs. 6 in FY23)
  • Offline expansion creating stickiness
  • Student accommodations (high-margin)
  • International expansion (61% YoY growth)

6. Better IPO Structure vs Pine Labs

  • Smaller OFS (only ₹380 crore vs ₹1,820 crore)
  • Founders selling modest stakes (confidence signal)
  • Fresh capital for growth (₹3,100 crore)

7. Favorable Market Dynamics

  • India’s education sector: $117B (2020) → $225B (2025)
  • Internet users: 622M (2020) → 900M (2025)
  • Smartphone penetration increasing in Tier 2/3 cities
  • Post-pandemic edtech acceptance

⚠️ Red Flags & Risks

1. Still Loss-Making at Net Level

  • FY25 net loss: ₹243 crore
  • Not yet achieved full profitability
  • Path to profitability uncertain

2. High Valuation (But Better Than Pine Labs)

  • Post-IPO valuation: ₹31,000 crore
  • 10x Revenue (vs. Veranda Learning at 4x, Career Point below 2x)
  • Pricing in significant future growth

3. 👥 High Employee Attrition

Period Attrition Rate
FY24 45.27%
FY25 36.51% (improved but still high)
Q1 FY26 37.72%

Risk: Losing quality faculty affects brand

4. Revenue Concentration Risks

  • NEET + JEE + Government exams = 54% of online users
  • Delhi NCR: 10.53% of revenue
  • Patna: 8.21% of revenue
  • Geographic + category concentration

5. Operational Expansion Risks

  • Rapid offline center expansion
  • Capex requirements: ₹1,208.7 crore
  • Managing 200+ offline centers complex
  • Quality control challenges

6. Competitive Pressures

  • Competition from traditional coaching (Allen, Aakash, Resonance)
  • Digital players (Unacademy, Vedantu – though struggling)
  • Free content on YouTube
  • Low switching costs for students

💡 Use of IPO Proceeds

Total Fresh Issue: ₹3,100 crore

  1. Capital Expenditure: ₹1,208.7 crore
    • New offline/hybrid centers: ₹460.55 crore
    • Lease payments: ₹378.16 crore
    • Server & cloud infrastructure: ₹369.99 crore
  2. Investment in Subsidiaries: ₹75.16 crore
    • Xylem Learning (hybrid learning)
    • Utkarsh Classes
  3. Inorganic Growth: ₹1,500 crore
    • Strategic acquisitions
    • Market expansion
  4. General Corporate Purposes

📈 Growth Catalysts

Offline Expansion

Doubling center count, hybrid model increases retention, higher ticket sizes

Category Expansion

6 categories (FY23) → 13 categories (FY25). Skill development, MBA prep, study abroad

International Growth

61% YoY growth. Middle East, Southeast Asia opportunities

Technology Leverage

AI reducing costs, personalized learning paths, better student outcomes

Market Boom

Rising aspirational middle class, Government focus on competitive exams

🎯 Investment Recommendation: PHYSICSWALLAH

Rating: ✅ SUBSCRIBE – LONG TERM (with moderate allocation)

Reasoning:

POSITIVES:

  1. Validated Business Model: EBITDA profitability achieved
  2. Strong Brand Moat: Most trusted edtech brand
  3. Affordable Pricing: Massive TAM in India
  4. Revenue Growth: 97% CAGR is exceptional
  5. Better IPO Structure: 89% fresh issue (capital for growth)
  6. Reasonable GMP: ₹3 premium (2.75% – conservative, stable)
  7. Relative Valuation: 10x revenue vs Pine Labs at 11x
  8. Market Opportunity: Education sector doubling by 2025

NEGATIVES:

  1. Still loss-making at net level (but improving)
  2. High valuation (10x revenue)
  3. Execution risks in offline expansion
  4. High attrition (faculty retention critical)
  5. Concentration risks (NEET/JEE dependency)

WHY BETTER THAN PINE LABS:

  1. Clearer path to profitability (EBITDA positive)
  2. Lower valuation premium given growth rate
  3. Less investor exit (small OFS)
  4. Stronger brand moat
  5. Better market sentiment (stable GMP)

📋 STRATEGY FOR INVESTORS

For Long-Term Investors (3-5 years):

  • ✅ SUBSCRIBE: Apply for 1 lot
  • 💼 ALLOCATION: 2-5% of equity portfolio (not more)
  • 📊 ENTRY STRATEGY: 50% on listing, 50% on dips
  • 📈 THESIS: India’s education boom + proven execution

For Short-Term Traders:

  • ⚖️ NEUTRAL: Expected listing gain 3-8%
  • ⚠️ RISK-REWARD: Not compelling for quick flip
  • 💡 BETTER STRATEGY: Wait for listing volatility

Risk Level

🟡 MODERATE-HIGH

Expected Listing Gain

3-8%

Long-Term Potential

🚀 HIGH
(if execution continues)

Target Price (18 months)

₹180-220
(65-100% upside potential)

⚖️ 3. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

Head-to-Head Comparison

Parameter Pine Labs PhysicsWallah Winner
Revenue CAGR 17% (FY23-25) 97% (FY23-25) 🏆 PW
Profitability 1 quarter profit EBITDA profitable 🏆 PW
Cash Flow Negative Improving 🏆 PW
Valuation (P/S) 11x revenue 10x revenue 🏆 PW
P/E Ratio 1,340x N/A (loss-making) –
OFS Component 47% (₹1,820 cr) 11% (₹380 cr) 🏆 PW
GMP Trend Crashed 88% Stable 🏆 PW
Brand Moat Moderate Very Strong 🏆 PW
Market Size ₹256T by FY29 $225B by 2025 🏆 Pine Labs
Execution Risk Moderate High 🏆 Pine Labs
Debt Levels Rising (25% D/E) Lower 🏆 PW
Business Model B2B (merchants) B2C (students) Subjective
OVERALL WINNER: PHYSICSWALLAH (8-3, 1 tie)

Sector Outlook

Fintech (Pine Labs)

Positives:

  • Massive TAM (digital payments boom)
  • Regulatory support for cashless economy

Concerns:

  • Intense competition (Paytm, PhonePe, Google Pay)
  • Margin pressure from UPI (zero MDR)
  • Regulatory uncertainties

EdTech (PhysicsWallah)

Positives:

  • Growing middle class demand
  • Government competitive exam focus
  • Less competition (Byju’s gone, Unacademy struggling)

Concerns:

  • Byju’s collapse (sector reputation damage)
  • Return to offline coaching trend
Verdict: EdTech has cleaner competitive landscape post-consolidation. PhysicsWallah is emerging as the clear winner in a sector that has seen significant cleanup.

🎯 4. FINAL INVESTMENT RECOMMENDATIONS

FOR DIFFERENT INVESTOR PROFILES

Investor Type Pine Labs PhysicsWallah
Conservative Investors
(Risk-Averse)		 ❌ AVOID ⚠️ SKIP
(wait for sustained profitability)
Moderate Risk Investors
(Balanced)		 ❌ AVOID
(at issue price)		 ✅ APPLY
(1 lot, 2-3% portfolio)
Aggressive Growth
Investors		 ⚠️ WAIT & WATCH
(buy post-listing at ₹150-170)		 ✅ APPLY
(2-3 lots, 5-8% portfolio)
HNI/Institutional
Investors		 ⚠️ PARTIAL ALLOCATION
(monitor closely)		 ✅ DECENT ALLOCATION

📊 Portfolio Allocation Recommendation

If investing ₹1,00,000 in IPOs:

Scenario 1 (Conservative)

  • Pine Labs: ₹0
  • PhysicsWallah: ₹0
  • Strategy: Keep cash for post-listing opportunities

Scenario 2 (Moderate)

  • Pine Labs: ₹0
  • PhysicsWallah: ₹30,000
  • Remaining: Other opportunities

Scenario 3 (Aggressive)

  • Pine Labs: ₹0 (wait for listing dip)
  • PhysicsWallah: ₹50,000
  • Strategy: Add Pine Labs at ₹150-170

👀 5. KEY RISKS TO MONITOR POST-LISTING

Pine Labs – Watch for:

  1. Q2, Q3 FY26 profitability – Is Q1 an aberration?
  2. Operating cash flow – Does it turn positive?
  3. Debt trajectory – Is leverage increasing?
  4. Top client retention – Any major loss?
  5. Competition intensity – Market share erosion?

PhysicsWallah – Watch for:

  1. FY26 net profitability – Can EBITDA convert to PAT?
  2. Offline expansion quality – Maintaining standards?
  3. Faculty attrition – Improving or worsening?
  4. Student retention rates – Sticky business?
  5. Competition response – Any major threats?

✅ 6. CONCLUSION & ACTION PLAN

🎯 Clear Action Items

PINE LABS:

  1. ❌ DO NOT APPLY for IPO at current valuation
  2. ⏰ SET ALERT for post-listing price at ₹150-170
  3. 📊 MONITOR Q2 FY26 results (Jan 2026)
  4. 💰 CONSIDER ENTRY only after 3 quarters of sustained profitability
  5. 🎯 TARGET ALLOCATION: Max 3-5% of equity portfolio (after correction)

PHYSICSWALLAH:

  1. ✅ APPLY for 1-2 lots (based on risk appetite)
  2. 📈 HOLD for 3-5 years (not for quick flip)
  3. 💰 AVERAGE DOWN if stock corrects 15-20% post-listing
  4. 📊 REVIEW quarterly results for sustained EBITDA growth
  5. 🎯 TARGET ALLOCATION: Max 5-8% of equity portfolio

💡 Smart Investor Strategy

Immediate Actions

  1. Apply for PhysicsWallah IPO (1 lot minimum)
  2. Skip Pine Labs IPO
  3. Keep cash ready for Pine Labs post-listing opportunity

3-Month Plan

  1. Monitor Pine Labs listing performance
  2. Track PhysicsWallah Q3 FY26 results
  3. Accumulate PhysicsWallah on dips (if fundamentals intact)

6-Month Plan

  1. Review Pine Labs profitability trajectory
  2. Consider entry if stock corrects to ₹150-170
  3. Assess PhysicsWallah offline expansion progress

💼 7. EXPERT INSIGHTS & MARKET CONTEXT

Why This Analysis Matters

Current Market Context (Nov 2025):

  • Nifty 50: Up 8% YTD, 3% below September highs
  • IPO market: Down 4.2% YoY, 29% fewer listings
  • Foreign investor interest: Improving
  • 6 IPOs currently open (including HDB Financial at $1.5B)

Sector Rotation:

  • Money flowing to proven business models
  • Loss-making companies facing valuation pressure
  • Market preference: Profitability > Growth

Historical Context

Sector Historical IPO Performance Relevance
Edtech IPOs Very few globally
US: Chegg, 2U (mixed performance)
India: PW would be FIRST major edtech IPO		 PhysicsWallah is breaking new ground
Fintech IPOs in India Paytm: Disastrous (-75% from issue price)
Policybazaar: Moderate (stabilized after fall)		 Pine Labs needs to avoid Paytm trajectory

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News